Nesje, F., Drupp, M.A., Freeman, M.C. and Groom, B. (2024) ‘Sense and sensitivity: an argument against reporting multiple net present values’, CESifo Working Paper No. 11547. Munich: CESifo (submitted). Available at: https://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:ces:ceswps:_11547
Abstract: In benefit-cost analysis, analysts frequently report not only a central net present value (NPV) but also multiple additional values, in what is commonly called NPV sensitivity analysis. This practice is generally justified on the grounds that the future net benefits of the asset are risky, or that the correct discounting model is difficult to identify, and it is recommended as best practice by several prestigious and influential sources. This paper explains why, despite these recommendations, reporting more than one NPV either lacks sufficient theoretical support or reflects decisions taken at an inappropriate level of the organisation, and may confuse decision-makers rather than inform them. The argument is illustrated using guidelines from both the public and private sectors, with particular focus on the US Environmental Protection Agency’s latest estimates of the social cost of carbon.
